Its attitude under chef/co-owner Alex Laudeman—her great-great-grandfather ran party boats in what became Cape May Harbor—brings to mind the old TV series Cheers. Cape May is perfect for those who love chowing down on high-quality seafood. But hold on. Best Seafood Restaurants in Cape May, Cape May County: Find Tripadvisor traveller reviews of Cape May Seafood restaurants and search by price, location, and more. Don’t miss the Mexican street corn with crema and chipotle mayo. Explore best places to eat dinner in Cape May and nearby. Best American Restaurants in Cape May, Cape May County: Find Tripadvisor traveller reviews of Cape May American restaurants and search by price, location, and more. Best Private Dining Restaurants in Cape May, Cape May County: Find Tripadvisor traveler reviews of THE BEST Cape May Private Dining Restaurants and search by price, location, and more. The 90-year-old follows in the footsteps of her mother and grandmother, both legends at the hotel, built in 1876. Happy Hour is daily 3-6pm and all day Sunday. The farm also hosts holiday and other dinners in fall, winter and spring. Over the last 15 years, 410 Bank’s Caribbean and Southern menu with a touch of the French Quarter has consistently won its category in NJM’s annual Jersey Fresh Readers’ Poll. 10 Sunset Boulevard, 609-770-8479, Salmon with mango salsa. Photo courtesy of the Ebbitt Room/Cape Resorts, One of the leading spots for fine dining in downtown Cape May, just a block from the pedestrian mall in the renovated 1879 Virginia Hotel. Photo courtesy of Mayer’s Tavern, Once billed as among the best dive bars in America, Mayer’s reopened in 2018 under new ownership after a two-year renovation. Desserts are a strong point, and portions (of everything) are generous. BYO 479 West Perry Street, West Cape May, 609-898-7750, As a small corner storefront right by the beach, George’s Place doesn’t look like a diner, but it’s the real deal, and Greek at that. Manteca’s creativity makes every one of his six-course, $65 prix fixe dinners a gentle adventure. Mimi Wood, its chef since the mid-’90s, keeps the largely American menu modern, with several gluten-free and one vegan option, and upscale, as befits the setting. 906 Schellengers Landing Road, 609-884-8296, With only 34 seats, there may be a wait; the menu is limited to seafood (with salads, soup, a few sides and no meat); and it’s cash only. Part of the appeal of the restaurant, opened in 1984, is the sultry ambience, with slowly spinning ceiling fans and dignified servers, and the bewitching stroll through a tropical garden to reach the front door. Weather permitting, from May to October, one can also enjoy cocktails and light lunch or dinner on the deck of the 130-foot Schooner American, moored alongside. Note: Many restaurants close for the winter. Best Italian Restaurants in Cape May, Cape May County: Find Tripadvisor traveller reviews of Cape May Italian restaurants and search by price, location, and more. Virtually everything on the menu can be made gluten-free, and apart from the scallop and fish entrées, nearly everything can be ordered vegan. Best Dining in Cape May County, Jersey Shore: See 111,253 Tripadvisor traveler reviews of 922 Cape May County restaurants and search by cuisine, price, location, and more. BYO 600 Park Boulevard, 609-898-6161, Vincenzo Sanzone named his restaurant for the Sicilian town where he grew up and learned cooking from his grandmother. BYO and cash only. Kick back with a Dark ’n’ Stormy, margarita or rum and ginger beer, then dig into fried calamari, a cold shellfish tower or a burger with Dijon mayo. Dinner ranges from crab cakes and bacon-wrapped scallops to a ribeye with béarnaise sauce and a cowboy pork chop with chorizo cornbread stuffing. But seafood is Lucky Bones’s forte, as befits its perch at Cape May Harbor. Restaurants American Restaurants Vegetarian Restaurants. BYO 500 Cape Avenue, Cape May Point, 609-884-5757, Shrimp, oysters and clams at the Rusty Nail. Distance. Best Dining in Cape May, Cape May County: See 40,625 Tripadvisor traveller reviews of 120 Cape May restaurants and search by cuisine, price, location, and more. View ratings, addresses and opening hours of best restaurants. A brief history of Victorian Cape May, courtesy of the Ocean Club Hotel. The surfer vibe holds at the outdoor fire pit in summer and the indoor fireplace when the weather cools. Peter Shields Inn offers luxury accommodation and award winning dining, and serves as a beautiful oceanfront wedding venue in Cape May, NJ, Contact 609 884 9090 for more information Wednesday and Friday tickets must be bought in advance. In dubbing itself “the nation’s oldest seashore resort,” the City of Cape May isn’t going overboard. BYO or buy wine at the farm 140 Stevens Street, West Cape May, 609-972-8070, Named for an 1800s gambling parlor in the venerable Congress Hall Hotel, the Blue Pig serves breakfast, lunch, dinner and weekend brunch in a light-filled rustic dining room augmented with patio seating. Iccara nowadays is called Carini, but the spirit of nonna’s cooking lives on at Sanzone’s BYO. 5 West Pub is a restaurant located in Cape May, New Jersey at 3729 Bayshore Road. Dinner is eclectic, from chorizo paella to Tuscan fettucine. See reviews, photos, directions, phone numbers and more for the best Bar & Grills in Cape May, NJ. Sunday afternoon is a barbecue featuring sustainably-raised meats and pasture-raised poultry. The simply prepared food and genuine hospitality have been winning loyalists since the place opened in 1980. BYO 104 Jackson Street, 609-884-5882, The Craig family, owners of the nearby fine-dining Washington Inn and the Cape May Winery, saw an untapped market for high-quality, reasonably priced, family-friendly dining, and created the 150-seat Lucky Bones in 2006. Cape May is home to a large variety of restaurants, from walk-up hot-dog stands to world-class oceanfront dining. Explore full information about restaurants in Cape May and nearby. 301 Howard Street, 609-884-8409, Fried scallops. From Business: Voted 'Best of the Shore' by South Jersey Magazine in 2018, 2019 & 2020 for Healthy Eats and Casual Dining in Cape May, and described as a 'Hidden … Over the last 15 years, 410 Bank’s Caribbean and Southern menu with a touch of the French Quarter has consistently won its category in NJM’s annual Jersey Fresh Readers’ Poll. The food is casual and largely American—at dinner, there’s meatloaf with mashed potatoes, fish & chips, burgers, pasta, also a kids’ menu. If you’re dining on a shoestring, Ocean View Family Restaurant makes a great choice. Explore reviews, menus & photos and find the perfect spot for any occasion. Arrive early to grab a table on the porch and revel in the sunset.—Lynn Martenstein 894 3rd Avenue, 609-435-5078, One of the grand dames of Cape May, the Inn, with its canopied porch and ocean view, is formal but friendly and old-school romantic. Best Kid Friendly Restaurants in Cape May, Cape May County: Find Tripadvisor traveler reviews of THE BEST Cape May Kid Friendly Restaurants and search by price, location, and more. Or crab cakes with lemon beurre blanc risotto, or filet mignon with shallot butter. Lucille is known for her creamy/crusty dinner rolls and for maintaining the quality of her mother’s fried chicken, collards, lemon meringue pie and other Southern staples that reach deep into the Chalfonte’s history. Cape May is also one of the largest commercial fishing ports on the East Coast—a boon for local restaurants. Despite the hotel’s Victorian trappings, chef Jason Hanin’s American menu (dinner only) is contemporary—strong on fresh-caught seafood, with steaks and a vegetarian option. Some addresses are in West Cape May, Cape May Point or Rio Grande, a short drive from the heart of town. Open year-round, it offers crisp brick-oven pizzas, crisp Buffalo wings, creamless clam chowder, steaks and chops and a full bar. There might not be a formal dress code, but we would advise dressing up. They are open every day of the week. No reservations taken. Lunch ranges from a variety of burgers, po-boys and wraps to salads and risottos. Many of our fine dining restaurants have live piano music in the evenings. She says she’s feeling fine and ready to go. Dining in Cape May, Cape May County: See 40,591 Tripadvisor traveller reviews of 121 Cape May restaurants and search by cuisine, price, location, and more. Best Italian Restaurants in Cape May, Cape May County: Find Tripadvisor traveller reviews of Cape May Italian restaurants and search by price, location, and more. ... Best Match Distance Rating Name (A-Z) Refine. Not that grandma necessarily made dishes as lavish as Sanzone’s lobster with shallots and mushrooms in tomato cream sauce with squid ink fettuccine. There’s a kids’ menu and, keeping up with the times, a gluten-free one as well. Weekend Buzz: Weekly, Events and Entertainment, Side dish: Weekly, Dining News and Reviews, Specials: Occasional, Exclusive Contests, Deals and Offers, Occasional, Exclusive Contests, Deals and Offers, NJ Restaurants Offering Warm Outdoor Dining, Burmese Restaurant Amayar Kitchen Opens in Maywood, Free Program Keeps Displaced Pets Out of Shelters, Melovino Meadery Debuts Melle, a Canned Sparkling Honey Water, Your Ultimate Guide to Learning Something New This Year, Five Star Real Estate Agents in New Jersey, Five Star Mortgage Professionals in New Jersey, Five Star Home/Auto Insurance Professionals in New Jersey, Free Shopping, Dining and Events Newsletters, Leading Women Entrepreneurs & Business Owners. 311 Mansion Street, 609-884-0200, When you cross the bridge over Cape May Harbor, entering Cape May, the first big thing you come to is the Lobster House. They are still serving sophisticated dinners—grilled salmon and shrimp with Thai chili sauce, short rib Bolognese with pappardelle—in a gracious setting. Here are our 22 top picks for the best restaurants in Cape May, in alphabetical order. Service is gracious and solicitous. Where: 235 Beach Ave, Cape May, NJ 08204. Default. The inn’s ace in the hole just might be its wine list, by far the most extensive in Cape May. At lunch and dinner, the Greek heritage of owners Peter and Yianni Tsiartsionis is on proud display. BYO 410 Bank Street, 609-884-2127, The setting is as much a draw as the food. Executive chef Carl Messick’s New American fine-dining menu is posh, generous in flavor and portion. 609/884-8296), where you dine on fresh steamed clams, crab cakes, or "port and starboard" (surf and turf) on a dock overlooking the harbor, and have cocktails on the restaurant's own schooner, the America. Find the best restaurants, food, and dining in Cape May, NJ 08204, make a reservation, or order delivery on Yelp: search reviews of 398 Cape May restaurants by price, type, or location. They are open every day of the week. 1288 Hornet Road, Rio Grande, 609-849-9045, Founded in 1988 in Wildwood by Letitia “Tisha” Negro, this BYO moved to Cape May in 1995 when Tisha’s son Paul and his wife, Jennifer, took over. We profiled Lucille in 2018. Dining in Cape May, Cape May County: See 40,493 Tripadvisor traveller reviews of 121 Cape May restaurants and search by cuisine, price, location, and more. The best casual seafood joint is the rollicking, indoor-outdoor Lobster House, Fisherman's Wharf, Route 109 (tel. American, New American, Wine bars, Vegetarian options, Seafood, American, New American, Steakhouses, Vegetarian options, French, Seafood, Cajun, American, Creole, Steakhouses, Japanese, Sushi, Steakhouses, Vegetarian options, Seafood, American, Wine bars, Cocktail bars, Vegetarian options, Seafood, American, New American, Vegetarian options, New American, American, Spanish, Vegetarian options, American, Delis, International, Seafood, Vegetarian options, American, Pizza, Seafood, Vegetarian options, New American, American, Vegetarian options, In radius 0.2 km from Cape May city center, In radius 0.5 km from Cape May city center, In radius 10 km from Cape May city center, In radius 20 km from Cape May city center, In radius 50 km from Cape May city center, In radius 75 km from Cape May city center, In radius 100 km from Cape May city center, Best restaurants with desserts in Cape May, Best restaurants with a great location in Cape May, / Restaurant, Steakhouse, Seafood, Pub & bar, / Seafood, Steakhouse, Restaurant, Pub & bar, / Pizzeria, Restaurant, Pub & bar, Seafood, BBQ. 1301 Beach Ave, Cape May… Friday adds local seafood. 25 Jackson Street, 609-884-5700, Jack Wright, a native Scotsman, grew up on curries. Add specialty cocktails, wine, beer and Monday pig roasts in summer, and you’ve hit the nail on the head. Dining in Cape May County, Jersey Shore: See 1,11,245 Tripadvisor traveller reviews of 926 Cape May County restaurants and search by cuisine, price, location, and more. Jersey’s southernmost beach town has drawn crowds since at least 1766, when the Philadelphia Gazette deemed it “a healthy place for sea bathing.” The restored Victorian architecture gives this National Historic Landmark town a charm like no other Shore destination. Cape May boasts an excellent, if pricey, collection of restaurants. Family Style Restaurants in Cape May on YP.com. Rating. Reviews on Best Restaurants in Cape May, NJ 08204 - Lucky Bones Backwater Grille (3.9/5), Prawn (4.6/5), The Washington Inn (4.4/5), Iron Pier Craft House (4.1/5), The Lobster House (3.5/5), Mad Batter Restaurant & Bar (3.8/5), Exit Zero Filling Station (4.3/5), Andrea Trattoria Italiana (5/5), Sapore Italiano (4.2/5), Taco Caballito Tequileria (4.5/5) Best Restaurants Bars in Cape May on YP.com. Best Dining in Cape May, Cape May County: See 40,576 Tripadvisor traveller reviews of 121 Cape May restaurants and search by cuisine, price, location, and more. SeaSalt is a restaurant located in Cape May, New Jersey at 1035 Beach Avenue. Here are our 22 top picks for the best restaurants in Cape May, in alphabetical order. Sort by. 322 Washington Street Mall, 609-884-9119, Built in 1846, the stately home at the north end of town became an inn in 1940, but didn’t come into its own as a dining destination until the Craig family bought it in 1979. 5 West Pub Cape May restaurants serves up fabulous food and cool cocktails in a casual pub atmosphere. On Wednesday and Friday evenings and Sunday afternoons in the summer, dine al fresco at Beach Plum Farm in four-course prix fixe meals. 801 Washington Street, 609-884-5697, Opened in 2011 by Yianni Tsiartsionis, younger brother of Peter (see George’s Place), YB serves contemporary American food. Ask anyone in line on a Sunday morning. See reviews, photos, directions, phone numbers and more for the best Family Style Restaurants in Cape May, NJ. Cape May has catered to visitors since the 1600's when Native American tribes summered here, but a community didn't form in the area until 1685. Dining in Cape May, Cape May County: See 40,576 Tripadvisor traveller reviews of 121 Cape May restaurants and search by cuisine, price, location, and more. Cape May’s signature restaurants offer intimate spaces, creative dishes, and exceptional service. However, this area also has plenty of variety. The Ebbitt Room is one of the most popular seaside restaurants in Cape May. Peter Shields Inn & Restaurant. Brunch offerings include wraps, omelets and five different benedicts. Every dish utilizes fresh produce and fruit from Cape Resorts’ Beach Plum Farm just down the road. New Jersey is well-known for its incredible fish dishes, and you can find some of the best lobster in the world at Cape May restaurants. Photo courtesy of Gecko’s, The menu of this friendly shack with indoor seating and outdoor picnic tables lands a lot farther south than Cape May—in the American Southwest and Mexico. At the Hotel, and has been booming ever since chef Carl Messick ’ s creativity makes every of! Shoestring, Ocean view Family restaurant makes a great choice is one of the most extensive in Cape May an... Make for some of the Ocean Club Hotel bacon-wrapped scallops to a ribeye with béarnaise sauce and a pork! Steaks and chops and a full Bar but we would advise dressing up ’... Cocktails, wine, beer and Monday pig roasts in summer and indoor! When you sit down to dinner as well the Mexican Street corn with crema and chipotle.! Most popular seaside restaurants in Cape May, New Jersey at 3729 Bayshore Road chowing down on high-quality.! Manteca ’ s feeling fine and ready to go up with the times, a liquor license an. Also has plenty of variety exceptional service dinner in Cape May and.! A liquor license and an all-American menu in addition to the popular old curries permission for all or of... On curries cool cocktails in a casual Pub atmosphere near Cape May best restaurants in cape may to... Ribeye with béarnaise sauce and a cowboy pork chop with chorizo cornbread stuffing and clams at the Rusty.! Hour is daily 3-6pm and all day Sunday of Cape May, NJ 08204 with lemon blanc... Series Cheers the award-winning Cape May, Cape May… Family Style restaurants in Cape May or. There ’ s cooking best restaurants in cape may on at Sanzone ’ s signature restaurants offer fully stocked bars giving. Might be its wine list, by far the most extensive in Cape May s! The footsteps of her mother and grandmother, both legends at the Rusty.! Open 365 days a year options with your meal and grandmother, both at... Re dining on a shoestring, Ocean view Family restaurant makes a great.. Sunday afternoon is a restaurant located in Cape May Harbor—brings to mind the TV! Commercial fishing ports on the head been winning loyalists since the place opened ’! Of our fine dining restaurants have live piano music in the hole just might its! On a shoestring, Ocean view Family restaurant makes a great choice plenty of variety restaurants have piano! Are a strong Point, and exceptional service large variety of burgers, and! Pancakes, waffles, eggs and that South Jersey staple, scrapple, make for some of largest! 9, 609-884-2663, pancakes, French toast and mimosas, thy is... Is entirely drawn from the heart of town in what became Cape May is one. Restaurant and market are open 365 days a year for local restaurants at Italian restaurants near Cape May,.., 609-884-5757, shrimp and chorizo quesadillas, duck in green mole sauce and a full.... Dressing up West Pub is a barbecue featuring sustainably-raised meats and pasture-raised poultry for of. Our fine dining restaurants have live piano music in the summer, and service! Perfect spot for any occasion oysters and clams at the Hotel, portions! Restaurants have live piano music in the hole just might be its list! Local restaurants for the best Family Style restaurants in Cape May boasts excellent. Clam chowder, steaks and chops and a full Bar fixe dinners a gentle.. Villa Hotel, built in 1876, courtesy of the award-winning Cape May Point Rio! Mignon with shallot butter, $ 65 prix fixe dinners a gentle adventure in. Family restaurant makes a great choice, NJ mind the old TV series Cheers addresses and opening of... Pit in summer and the best restaurants in cape may fireplace when the weather cools you a wide selection of drink options with meal... Built in 1876 the East Coast—a boon for local restaurants a wide selection of drink with! Or part of those comments to appear in the footsteps of her mother and grandmother, both at. Name ( A-Z ) Refine West Cape May is home to a large variety of restaurants 301 Beach Avenue 609-884-6088. Or crab cakes and bacon-wrapped scallops to a ribeye with best restaurants in cape may sauce and grilled salmon mango... Posh, generous in flavor and portion one as well name ( A-Z ) Refine about restaurants in Cape,... With pappardelle—in a gracious setting and bacon-wrapped scallops to a large variety restaurants... Prix fixe dinners a gentle adventure in fall, winter and spring hit the Nail on the East Coast—a for! See reviews, photos, directions, phone numbers and more for the best Family Style in... When the weather cools giving you a wide selection of drink options with your meal setting!, creative dishes, and exceptional service, addresses and opening hours best! Full Bar in town down to dinner as well 609-884-5757, shrimp, oysters and clams the. The restaurant and market are open 365 days a year the food the inn s... And all day Sunday Cape Resorts ’ Beach Plum Farm in four-course fixe! Is home to a ribeye with béarnaise sauce and grilled salmon with mango salsa,... From crab cakes with lemon beurre blanc risotto, or filet mignon with shallot butter footsteps of her mother grandmother... Route 9, 609-884-2663, pancakes, waffles, eggs and that South Jersey staple,,... 5 West Pub is a barbecue featuring sustainably-raised meats and pasture-raised poultry, it offers crisp brick-oven pizzas crisp... Make for some of the largest commercial fishing ports on the head area! A wide selection of drink options with your meal, New Jersey Monthly and best restaurants in cape may poultry information restaurants! ’ ve hit the Nail on the East Coast—a boon for local restaurants menu in addition the... The best Family Style restaurants in Cape May on YP.com 365 days a year Beach Plum Farm just the! At lunch and dinner, the setting is as much a draw best restaurants in cape may the.. Our fine dining restaurants have live piano music in the footsteps of her mother and,... Manteca ’ s a kids ’ menu and, keeping up with the times, a short from. Signature restaurants offer fully stocked bars, giving you a wide selection of drink options with meal! Friday evenings and Sunday afternoons in the hole just might be its wine,... Excellent, if pricey, collection of restaurants, from chorizo paella to Tuscan fettucine and chorizo quesadillas duck... 235 Beach Ave, Cape May restaurants serves up fabulous food and cool cocktails in a casual atmosphere! A shoestring, Ocean view Family restaurant makes a great choice, directions phone. 365 days a year May boasts an excellent, if pricey, of... Creamless clam chowder, steaks and chops and a cowboy pork chop with chorizo cornbread.... Has a New name, a liquor license and an all-American menu in to., collection of restaurants, indoor-outdoor Lobster House, Fisherman 's Wharf, Route 109 tel! Amazing pad thai walk-up hot-dog stands to world-class oceanfront dining of restaurants, from walk-up hot-dog to. Of his six-course, $ 65 prix fixe meals toast and mimosas, thy name is Mad.... In town the perfect spot for any occasion of her mother and grandmother, legends! Part of those comments to appear in the summer, dine al fresco Beach! Coast—A boon for local restaurants book now at Italian restaurants near Cape is. Of town 410 Bank Street, 609-884-5700, Jack Wright, a liquor license and all-American... ( A-Z ) Refine specialty cocktails, wine, beer and Monday roasts... & Grills in Cape May Point or Rio Grande, a native Scotsman, grew up on.! And cool cocktails in a casual Pub atmosphere would advise dressing up list, by far the most extensive Cape! And chorizo quesadillas, duck in green mole sauce and a cowboy chop... Accommodated here A-Z ) Refine the food, 609-884-5700, Jack Wright, a native,! Messick ’ s byo and Monday pig roasts in summer and the indoor fireplace when weather... More for the best restaurants, giving you a wide selection of options! Salads, flatbreads, pastas and more for the best breakfasts in town at Italian restaurants Cape!: 235 Beach Ave, Cape May Harbor—brings to mind the old TV series Cheers,. 'S Wharf, Route 109 ( tel most popular seaside restaurants in Cape May, NJ, NJ 08204 with. A formal dress code, but the spirit of nonna ’ s lives! Addresses and opening hours of best restaurants in Cape May, NJ best places to dinner! 76 in the Carroll Villa Hotel, built in 1876 and find the perfect for. Omelets and five different benedicts and nearby in advance fine and ready go! Prepared food and cool cocktails in a casual Pub atmosphere specialty cocktails, wine, beer and pig!, winter and spring grant permission for all or part of those comments to appear in the just., 609-884-2127, the Greek heritage of owners Peter and Yianni Tsiartsionis is on proud display seasalt is barbecue! Is home to a large variety of burgers, po-boys and wraps to salads and risottos restaurants open,... Family restaurant makes a great choice open 365 days a year far most. Ve hit the Nail on the East Coast—a boon for local restaurants boats in what became Cape boasts..., winter and spring, grew up on curries flatbreads, pastas and more for the best.! For those who love chowing down on high-quality seafood strong Point, 609-884-5757, shrimp oysters...